Home / Daily Dose / Defects on the Rise, Highest in North Dakota
Print This Post Print This Post

Defects on the Rise, Highest in North Dakota

Loan application defects are on the rise, according to the First American Loan Application Defect Index released on Wednesday. Compared to a year ago, the Defect Index has increased 8 percent.

First American’s Defect Index, which measures the frequency of defects, misrepresentation, and fraud on loan applications, was up 2.5 percent over the month in April and 8 percent over the year.

According to Mark Fleming, Chief Economist at First American, April marked the fifth month in a row the Index has increased.

“The Loan Application Defect Index continued its strong upward increase for the fifth consecutive month,” Fleming said. “The pace of defect risk growth is as strong as we have seen since the index began in 2011, adding to the concern over the five-month trend.”

According to Fleming, the uptick is due to riskier lending practices as of late.

“While we have recently noted that part of the rise in overall risk is due to the market’s shift toward riskier purchase transactions,” Fleming said, “the fact that risk in refinance transactions is also on the rise underscores the need for caution.”

On refinance transactions specifically, the frequency of defects was up 4.8 percent for the month and 3.1 percent for the year. On purchase transactions, it was up 2.3 percent and 7.2 percent, respectively.

At the state level, Defect Index was highest in North Dakota (96 out of 100), Montana (95), Vermont (94), Louisiana (93), and Mississippi (93). The biggest jumps in the Defect Index took place in South Dakota (49.1 percent rise over the year), Wyoming (43.5 percent), North Dakota (39.1 percent), West Virginia (35.1 percent), and Iowa (29.5 percent). The only states to see a decrease in defect frequency were Connecticut and Oklahoma.

As for the riskiest metros, the Defect Index was highest in McAllen, Texas (110); Knoxville, Tennessee (98); Charleston, South Carolina (97); Tampa, Florida (95); and Birmingham, Alabama (94). The largest increases in defect frequency were seen in Raleigh, North Carolina (32.8 percent); New Orleans (18.2 percent); Tampa (17.3 percent); Jacksonville, Florida (16.5 percent); and Birmingham (14.6 percent). The city with the biggest decrease in defect frequency was Milwaukee, with a 10.1 percent dip over last year.

Despite the recent uptick in defect frequency, the Defect Index is still well below its peak. April’s Index was 20.6 percent lower than its highest point, reached in October 2013. To see the full Defect Index for the month, visit Blog.FirstAm.com.

About Author: Aly J. Yale

Aly J. Yale is a longtime writer and editor from Texas. Her resume boasts positions with The Dallas Morning News, NBC, PBS, and various other regional and national publications. She has also worked with both the Five Star Institute and REO Red Book, as well as various other mortgage industry clients on content strategy, blogging, marketing, and more.

Check Also


Study Shows Americans Ill-Prepared for Flooding

During a time of increased mortgage delinquencies, storm surges can have an even more devastating effect on those who are underinsured, experts say.


Featuring daily updates on foreclosure, REO, and the secondary market, DS News has the timely and relevant content you need to stay at the top of your game. Get each day’s most important default servicing news and market information delivered directly to your inbox, complimentary, when you subscribe.