While selling a home may pose its fair share of challenges, especially in pricey U.S. metros, roughly one of every eight (12.3%) homes that sold in San Francisco during the three months ending July 31 was purchased for less than the seller bought it for. That's up from 5% a year earlier, representing a higher share than any other major U.S. metro and quadruple the national rate of 3%. according to a new report from Redfin. Next came Detroit (6.9%), Chicago (6.5%), New York (5.9%), and Cleveland (5.8%).
Nationwide, the typical homeowner who sold their home for less than they bought it for lost $35,538. In San Francisco, the typical homeowner who took a loss sold their home for $100,000 less than they bought it for. San Francisco also tied with New York for the largest median loss in dollar terms.
Homeowners were least likely to sell at a loss in San Diego, Boston, Providence, RI, Kansas City, MO, and Fort Lauderdale, FL. In each of those metros, roughly 1% of homes sold for less than the seller originally paid.
San Francisco Homeowners Take Big Hit Due to Plunge in Home Prices
San Francisco home sellers were most likely to lose money because the region has experienced outsized home price declines. It was one of the first markets to see prices sink when high mortgage rates triggered a slowdown in the housing market last year. By April 2023, San Francisco’s median home sale price was down a record 13.3% year over year, more than triple the nationwide drop of 4.2%.
As of July, it was down just 4.3% year over year to $1.4 million, but that compared with a national gain of 1.6%. The total value of homes in San Francisco has fallen by roughly $60 billion since last summer, a separate Redfin analysis found.
Prices in the Bay Area have fallen fast for a few reasons: First, it’s home to the most expensive real estate in the country, meaning housing costs had a lot of room to come down. It has also been hit hard by layoffs in the technology sector. Additionally, it’s not as popular as it once was; remote work has allowed scores of people to relocate to more affordable areas.
San Francisco, Detroit, Chicago, and New York, which top the list of metros where home sellers are most likely to take a loss, all rank among the top 10 metros Redfin.com users are looking to leave.
“Some condos in the Bay Area are now worth less than their owners bought them for in 2018 and 2019, in part because commuting from Oakland and other outlying areas into downtown San Francisco isn’t really a thing anymore,” said local Redfin Premier real estate agent Andrea Chopp, who focuses on Oakland and other East Bay neighborhoods. “There are buyers out there, but they’re a lot more cautious and picky than they were when mortgage rates were low. The Bay Area housing market was unsustainable before, so this correction is probably healthy, but the unfortunate thing is prices remain unaffordable for a lot of people—especially with rates now above 7%.”
The Majority of U.S. Home Sellers Continue to Reap Financial Gains
Even though home prices have fallen from their peak, a vast majority of home sellers are still reaping significant financial gains. Nationwide, 97% of home sellers sold for a profit during the three months ending July 31, with the typical home that sold going for 78.4% ($203,232) more than the seller bought it for. The typical home that sold in San Francisco went for 70.5% ($625,500) more than the seller bought it for.
Today’s home sellers are making money despite an ongoing housing downturn, in part because a scarcity of homes for sale is fueling bidding wars and propping up home values. Most people who bought when home prices peaked would lose money if they sold now, so they’re not selling. Many of the homeowners who are selling today have owned their homes for long enough to make a profit regardless of month-to-month fluctuations in housing values.
In Boise, ID, Redfin Premier agent Shauna Pendleton has clients who will likely have to take a $100,000 loss on their home because they’re selling it after only about a year. They’re moving back to Seattle because their employer is requiring them to return to the office. Pendleton noted that it’s not common for homeowners to sell at a loss in Boise, but when it does happen, it often involves homes selling for upwards of $750,000.
To read the full report including more data, charts, and methodology, click here.